›

Legal Counsel’s Corner: Washington Prevailing Wages, Sun Valley at the Supreme Court, and 2027 State Law Changes

Legal Counsel’s Corner: Washington Prevailing Wages, Sun Valley at the Supreme Court, and 2027 State Law Changes

Legal Counsel’s Corner: Washington Prevailing Wages, Sun Valley at the Supreme Court, and 2027 State Law Changes

por Barron Dickinson

Categorías: Legal

Quick listen (3 min)

0:00/1:34

Agricultural Industry Litigation Update

Washington Federal Court Issues Another Ruling in Familias Unidas v. DOL & New Prevailing Wage Rates: What Washington H-2A Employers Need to Know

On November 6, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington issued a long-awaited summary judgment ruling in Familias Unidas por la Justicia v. U.S. Department of Labor (No. 2:24-cv-00637). In the case, the farmworker union challenged how DOL sets and approves Washington’s H-2A prevailing wage rates. The court rejected most of the union’s claims. It upheld the rule that prevailing wages expire one year after posting (the “One-Year Rule”). It upheld the rule barring a prevailing wage finding when a single employer accounts for more than 25% of the sampled wages (the “25% Rule”) and DOL’s use of population estimates in its surveys.

However, the union won on one issue. The court found that DOL acted arbitrarily in approving the 2022 Washington survey results because the Washington SWA had split piece-rate pay into separate subcategories, such as piece rates with hourly guarantees or with bonuses, and treated each as its own “unit of pay.” This “wage fracturing” produced “no finding” results for activities such as Fuji apple harvesting, where the data otherwise pointed to a piece-rate prevailing wage.

Importantly, the court did not set replacement 2022 wages or order any retroactive payments. Instead, it directed the parties to submit remedy proposals by December 4, 2026. Therefore, employers have no back-pay obligation arising from the decision at this time. Whether historical wage obligations come into play will depend on what remedy the court ultimately imposes and on any recalculation by DOL.

The more immediate issue for Washington employers is the Notice of Wage Adjustment that DOL’s Office of Foreign Labor Certification (OFLC) sent last week, dated November 10, 2026. It announced new statewide prevailing wages for six activities:

  • Cosmic Crisp apple harvesting: $36.31 per bin

  • Apple thinning: $19.15 per hour

  • Berry harvesting: $17.54 per hour

  • Bartlett pear harvesting: $29.37 per bin

  • D’Anjou pear harvesting: $31.14 per bin

  • General pear harvesting: $30.61 per bin

Bin rates are for a standard 47” x 47” x 24.5” bin. These rates come from the latest Washington survey, posted on October 30, 2026, on DOL’s Agricultural Online Wage Library. Employers should check the library for every crop activity and task in their job order before filing.

When reading the AOWL library, keep these terms in mind:

  • Active: the current, governing result for that activity. It may be a wage rate or a “No Finding.”

  • No Finding: the survey did not produce a valid prevailing wage. Most activities in the new Washington survey, including most apple and cherry tasks, came back as “No Finding.” For these activities, employers must offer and pay the highest of the following: the AEWR, any agreed-upon collective bargaining wage, the federal or state minimum wage, any other rate the employer intends to pay, or a prevailing wage already guaranteed on the job order.

  • Archive: a prior finding that has been replaced. An archived rate no longer applies to new job orders. It still matters only if it was guaranteed on a job order that is still in effect.

Employers should also keep longstanding rules on mid-contract wage changes in mind:

  • Prevailing wage goes up: if it exceeds the otherwise applicable wage, the employer must pay the higher rate starting on the date of DOL’s notice, which here is November 10, 2026.

  • Prevailing wage goes down: the employer must keep paying at least the rate guaranteed on its job order.

  • Prevailing wage expires: if a guaranteed prevailing wage expires during the contract, the employer must keep paying at least the expired rate.

Finally, the court upheld the One-Year Rule, but OFLC’s notice says the existing injunction against applying it in Washington remains in effect for now. As a result, the new rates stay valid until they are replaced, pending final resolution of the case. Seso will keep following the remedy proceedings and will update clients on any developments.

Supreme Court Hears Oral Argument in DOL v. Sun Valley Orchards

On November 10, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court (SCOTUS) heard oral argument in Department of Labor v. Sun Valley Orchards (No. 25-966). In the first case to ever reach the high court involving the H-2A program, SCOTUS will soon decide whether DOL can use its own administrative law judges to impose back wages and civil penalties on employers for H-2A violations, or whether those claims must be tried in federal court.

As Seso previously reported, the case began when DOL accused Sun Valley Orchards, a family farm in New Jersey, of violating H-2A requirements during the 2015 season, including requirements for meals and living conditions. An ALJ ordered the farm to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars in back wages and penalties, and DOL’s Administrative Review Board affirmed. The Third Circuit later held that Sun Valley was entitled to have the claims heard in federal court. The government defends its in-house process on the ground that immigration is a “public rights” area that Congress can assign to the executive branch. Sun Valley argues the dispute is essentially a private employment and contract matter.

The justices sent mixed signals during the nearly two-hour argument. Several conservative justices expressed sympathy with Sun Valley’s position, and Chief Justice Roberts drew a line between admitting workers through H-2A and the employment conditions that come afterward. However, some conservatives also appeared hesitant to go much further in limiting agency power. Justices Kagan, Sotomayor, and Jackson stressed that immigration was central to the case. Justice Kagan suggested the alleged violations looked like a form of visa fraud. The case follows the Court’s 2024 decision in SEC v. Jarkesy, which limited the SEC’s use of in-house proceedings to impose fines, and the ruling here could affect agency enforcement well beyond labor law.

H-2A employers left the hearing feeling cautiously optimistic about their chances of prevailing. Fisher Phillips’ agriculture team predicts a 6-3 decision for Sun Valley in the first half of 2027. If Sun Valley prevails, DOL would have to bring these claims in federal court, which could significantly reduce H-2A employers’ exposure to back wage and civil monetary penalty liability. Regardless of the outcome, the substantive H-2A requirements for wages, housing, transportation, and the three-quarters guarantee stay in place, so employers should continue to make continued compliance the highest operational priority. Seso will keep a close eye on this case and will update clients when the Court issues its decision.

Federal Court Upholds DHS’s H-2 Modernization Rule Against Employer Challenge

On October 30, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas rejected a challenge to the Department of Homeland Security’s (DHS) H-2 Modernization Rule brought by national agricultural and seasonal employer trade associations. The case is Federation of Employers and Workers of America v. Mullin (No. 3:25-cv-14). As Seso previously reported, the rule took effect on January 17, 2025, and made significant changes to the H-2A and H-2B programs.

The associations sued under the Administrative Procedure Act to set aside two of its key provisions. The first lets USCIS deny an H-2 petition if the employer violated “any applicable employment-related laws or regulations” during the three years before filing. The second requires USCIS to deny or revoke a petition when prohibited recruitment fees were collected. That applies whether the fees were collected by the employer, by its employees, or anywhere else in the recruitment chain, unless the employer proves it made “ongoing, good faith, reasonable efforts” to prevent and detect them. The associations argued that the three-year lookback was impermissibly retroactive and that both standards were unconstitutionally vague.

The court granted summary judgment to DHS on every claim. It found the lookback is not retroactive because denial is discretionary, not mandatory, and applies only to petitions filed after the rule took effect. It also found that both standards are clear enough for employers who already certify compliance with “employment-related laws” on their H-2 forms, especially because DHS listed specific factors it will weigh case by case.

Unless the decision is appealed and reversed, DHS’s H-2 rule remains fully in effect, and the fee provision is the one that deserves employers’ attention. Illegal fees charged to workers by recruiters and other intermediaries, often in the workers’ home countries and outside the employer’s view, have historically been one of the hardest problems for H-2 employers to solve. The rule makes the employer effectively strictly liable for those fees: a petition must be denied or revoked even if the employer did not know about them, unless it can document good-faith prevention efforts. DHS has pointed to several practices that show good faith:

  • Paying recruiters enough that they have no incentive to pass costs on to workers

  • Monitoring every party in the recruitment chain, at home and abroad

  • Keeping a direct line of communication with workers so reports of prohibited fees can be investigated

The lookback provision also raises the stakes of Wage & Hour Division (WHD) and related federal/state audits. Form I-129 now asks employers to disclose violations from the past three years, and DHS has new discretionary authority to deny petitions for non-compliance. That makes it more important than ever to appeal an initial violation finding after a WHD audit, rather than accepting it and paying a penalty. Once an employer discloses a past violation and submits evidence of its commitment to compliance, DHS’s rule indicates the employer should not have trouble getting future petitions approved based on that same violation, unless new information comes to light.

H-2 employers should continue to periodically review their recruiter agreements and worker-communication practices to ensure they are protecting themselves both contractually and in practice. When disclosing a past violation, employers should also include thorough documentation of how it was resolved. Seso will keep watching for an appeal and will update clients on any developments.

Court Dismisses Florida Growers Association’s Challenge to DOL’s 2023 AEWR Rule as Moot

On November 6, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida dismissed Florida Growers Association, Inc. v. Su (Case No. 8:23-cv-00889). In this lawsuit, Florida Growers Association (FGA) argued that the Department of Labor’s (DOL) 2023 rule raising Adverse Effect Wage Rates (AEWR) for H-2A workers violated the Administrative Procedure Act and the Regulatory Flexibility Act. The case had been on hold. DOL then asked the court to dismiss it as moot because the 2023 AEWR Rule had been replaced by DOL’s Interim Final Rule (IFR), which took effect on October 2, 2025. FGA argued in response that the case was still live because the 2025 IFR carries over the same “fatal flaws” as the 2023 Rule. It also argued that DOL changed the rule only to escape litigation. The court rejected both arguments. It held that FGA’s amended complaint challenged only the 2023 AEWR Rule, which is no longer in effect, and so presented no live controversy. It also found that DOL replaced the 2023 AEWR rule to comply with a federal court order in a related Louisiana federal court case, Teche Vermilion Sugar Cane Growers Assoc. v. DOL, not to manipulate the court’s jurisdiction.

The dismissal was without prejudice and did not decide whether the 2023 AEWR Rule was lawful. The court said FGA is free to challenge the 2025 IFR. To do so, it must file a new complaint that specifically names the 2025 IFR as the regulation under challenge. In a footnote, the court also clarified that the Louisiana injunction against the 2023 AEWR Rule was not nationwide, as DOL had described it. That injunction covered only the named Louisiana sugar cane employers. For employers, the practical takeaway is that the 2023 AEWR litigation has finally concluded and all eyes are now on the forthcoming new AEWR methodology that DOL has been ordered to publish by December 30, 2026, following the Eastern District of California’s decision finding the 2025 IFR unlawful. Seso will keep watching for new filings and will update clients on any developments affecting H-2A wage obligations.

Federal Regulatory Update

CBP Ends Routine Passport Admission Stamps: What H-2A Employers Should Do Now

In an October 1, 2026 bulletin, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) announced that officers will no longer routinely stamp passports at primary inspection. Proof of admission, authorized stay, and five years of arrival history will now come from the electronic Form I-94, available on the CBP I-94 website or the CBP Link mobile app. Stamps will still be used in secondary inspection, for immigrant visas, or when a traveler asks for one. The change does not affect the visa foil issued by a U.S. consulate. The vast majority of H-2A employers should be accustomed to retrieving electronic I-94 at this point, as CBP has steadily shifted towards electronically capturing entrances over the last several years.

Employers should remind workers before they travel that they can still ask the CBP officer for a stamp, especially at land ports. Officers don’t have to grant the request, but a stamp gives the worker a backup record of entry. Within a few days of arrival, each worker should pull up their I-94 and confirm that the name, the H-2A classification, and the “admit until” date are correct. Errors should be fixed right away through the port of entry or a CBP Deferred Inspection office. Employers should keep a copy of each I-94 on file for Form I-9, petition extensions, transfers, and audits.

Departures need the same attention. CBP generally records departures from airline and carrier manifests, so land departures, which are most common among H-2A workers, are usually missing from the electronic travel records available on CBP’s websites. Seso has seen a recent increase in USCIS Requests for Evidence (RFEs) asking H-2A employers to document workers’ travel histories and departures for the past three years. Under DHS’s H-2 Modernization Rule, an absence of at least 60 days outside the United States resets the three-year limit on H-2A stay. A worker who reaches that limit must also stay outside the country for 60 days before being readmitted.

To be ready for these RFEs, employers should collect proof of departure at the end of each season rather than after an RFE arrives. The strongest submissions combine several sources:

  • CBP travel history and I-94 printouts, or CBP records requested through FOIA

  • Bus or airline tickets and receipts for border crossings

  • Employer records showing the last day worked, the final paycheck, and payment for return transportation

  • A new visa issued at a U.S. consulate abroad

  • Dated records from the home country, such as receipts, money transfers, local pay stubs, or utility bills

  • A signed declaration from the worker, as supporting evidence only

Seso will continue to monitor RFE trends and will update clients as they develop.

2027 State Law Roundup: What H-2A Employers Need to Know

H-2A program rules already require employers to comply with all applicable federal, state, and local laws. However, USCIS also now has broad discretion to deny H-2A petitions over past violations, and the industry has seen consular posts use extended administrative processing during program integrity investigations to keep employers from receiving workers, often with little notice or chance to respond. The stakes have never been higher. Non-compliance can cost employers their workforce for the season leading to catastrophic financial losses. As employers finalize 2027 budgets and job orders, they must take into account new state law requirements in order to ensure their continued compliance and access to the program.

California: Foreign Labor Contractor Registration Requirements Expand to H-2A (AB 1362)

California’s Labor Commissioner’s Office (LCO) has notified stakeholders that, starting July 1, 2027, its Foreign Labor Contractor (FnLC) registration program will cover anyone who recruits H-2A workers for jobs in California. The change comes following the enactment of Assembly Bill 1362. Until now, the program applied only to recruiters of H-2B workers. Licensed Farm Labor Contractors who also do foreign labor contracting will have to register separately as FnLCs.

A “foreign labor contractor” is anyone who recruits or solicits workers living outside the United States for California jobs in exchange for compensation. The regulations define “recruiting” broadly. It includes enticing, hiring, transporting, or otherwise processing workers, and “processing” covers interviewing, testing, screening, scheduling consular visa appointments, and referring workers to employers. Registration is not required when an employer recruits workers itself, or when one of its own employees recruits solely for that employer.

Once the expansion takes effect, registered contractors must give each worker a written disclosure (Form DLSE 703) at the time of recruitment, in English and in the worker’s primary language. It must include:

  • The employer’s and recruiter’s identities, along with any subcontractors or agents

  • A signed work contract

  • The visa type

  • An itemized list of costs

Contractors must also file the executed disclosure with the LCO within seven days. Employers that know, or should have known, that they are using an FnLC must file their own disclosure (Form DLSE 704) and update it within 15 days of any change (Form DLSE 704A). This applies even if the employer did not recruit the workers directly. Employers may not knowingly contract with an unregistered FnLC. Violations carry civil penalties of up to $25,000 per violation, and damages of $500 per worker for a first violation and $1,000 per worker for each later one. Violations can also be prosecuted as misdemeanors.

Recruiters and employers should start preparing now. Any recruiter, agent, or Farm Labor Contractor that takes part in recruiting or processing H-2A workers for California, including scheduling consular appointments, should plan to register before July 1, 2027. Registration requires:

The LCO expects to open an online application before the deadline. California employers should take three steps:

  • Identify every third party in their H-2A recruitment chain, both in the U.S. and abroad.

  • Confirm that each one plans to register.

  • Plan to check registration status in the LCO’s online Registered Foreign Labor Contractor Database before signing or renewing service agreements.

Employers should also review their recruiter agreements to require registration and compliance with the disclosure rules. Forms, required documents, and updates are on the LCO’s FnLC registration page. Questions can be sent to foreignlaborcon@dir.ca.gov.

Oregon: Agricultural Overtime Drops to 40 Hours

Starting January 1, 2027, Oregon’s agricultural overtime threshold drops from 48 hours to 40 hours a week. This is the final step of the phase-in that began in 2023. The Bureau of Labor and Industries (BOLI) explains the change, along with the limited exemptions and how the law defines agricultural work, on its Minimum Wage and Overtime in Agriculture page and in its Agricultural Overtime employer guide. BOLI also publishes a bilingual Know Your Rights flyer for agricultural workers that reflects the 2027 change, and employers can share it with their crews.

Overtime is paid at one and one-half times the worker’s regular rate, it is calculated by the workweek rather than the pay period, and it applies to H-2A workers and corresponding domestic workers alike. A few limited exemptions remain, including for members of the employer’s immediate family, certain local piece-rate hand-harvest and pruning workers, and salaried employees who meet specific criteria. The Department of Revenue’s Agricultural Employer Overtime Tax Credit guidance explains how the refundable credit offsets part of the overtime cost. For employers with more than 25 full-time-equivalent employees, the credit falls from 30% in 2026 to 15% in 2027.

Employers should make sure any job order covering work in 2027 discloses the 40-hour threshold. They should also set the anticipated weekly hours with both the higher overtime cost and the three-quarters guarantee in mind. Finally, they should update payroll to calculate overtime correctly by the workweek for piece-rate workers, and apply between January 1 and January 31, 2027, for the credit on overtime paid in 2026.

Colorado: Agricultural Overtime Threshold Rises to 56 Hours (SB26-121)

Colorado is moving in the other direction. Starting January 1, 2027, SB26-121 sets a single 56-hour weekly overtime threshold for most agricultural employees year-round. It replaces the current system of 48 hours off-season and 56 hours during up to 22 peak weeks for highly seasonal employers. Employees principally engaged in range livestock production, family members of the employer, and decision-making managers remain exempt. The law also raises penalties for employers that fail to pay wages or misclassify employees three or more times within a five-year period.

The Colorado Department of Labor and Employment (CDLE) has not yet published guidance on the new law. Its current INFO #12A on agricultural overtime and minimum wage and its 2026 COMPS Order poster still describe the rules in effect through December 31, 2026, and both are expected to be updated before the new threshold takes effect.

SB26-121 is not retroactive: the 56-hour threshold applies only to hours worked on or after January 1, 2027, so overtime earned under the current 48/56-hour rules through December 31, 2026 must still be paid in full. It is less clear how the new threshold interacts with certified job orders that run into 2027 and promise overtime after 48 hours. Whether that promise remains an enforceable contract term once the state requirement changes is unsettled, so the best practice is to honor the overtime terms in any certified job order for the life of the contract. Job orders filed for 2027 can reflect the new 56-hour threshold. Employers should also update payroll for the January 1 change, confirm that every worker treated as exempt actually qualifies, and watch for CDLE’s updated guidance and posters.

Employers in every state should also watch scheduled state minimum wage increases, which now raise H-2A wage obligations directly wherever the state minimum exceeds the AEWR. Seso will continue to monitor state legislation and will update clients as new requirements take effect.

Aviso legal: La información proporcionada en este blog es solo para fines informativos generales. Toda la información en el sitio se proporciona de buena fe, sin embargo, no hacemos representación o garantía de ningún tipo, expresa o implícita, con respecto a la exactitud, adecuación, validez, confiabilidad, disponibilidad o integridad de cualquier información en el sitio. En ningún caso tendremos responsabilidad hacia usted por cualquier tipo de pérdida o daño incurrido como resultado del uso del sitio o la confianza en cualquier información proporcionada en el sitio. Su uso del sitio y su confianza en cualquier información en el sitio es únicamente bajo su propio riesgo.


El blog puede contener enlaces a otros sitios web o contenido perteneciente u originado por terceros o enlaces a sitios web y características en banners u otra publicidad. Tales enlaces externos no son investigados, monitoreados o verificados por nosotros en cuanto a su exactitud, adecuación, validez, confiabilidad, disponibilidad o integridad. No garantizamos, respaldamos, garantizamos o asumimos la responsabilidad de la exactitud o confiabilidad de cualquier información ofrecida por sitios web de terceros enlazados a través del sitio o cualquier sitio web o característica enlazada en cualquier banner u otra publicidad. No seremos parte o de ninguna manera seremos responsables de monitorear cualquier transacción entre usted y proveedores de productos o servicios de terceros.

¿Listo para aprender más?